White Rose University Consortium logo
University of Leeds logo University of Sheffield logo York University logo

Gramsci and the German Crisis, 1929-34 : a historical interpretation of the Prison Notebooks

Overy, Stephen (2001) Gramsci and the German Crisis, 1929-34 : a historical interpretation of the Prison Notebooks. PhD thesis, University of York.

[img] Text (247031.pdf)
247031.pdf - Examined Thesis (PDF)

Download (31Mb)

Abstract

This thesis investigates how far the political theory of Gramsci's Prison Notebooks (1929-35) had its immediate origins in the crisis going on in Germany at the time he wrote them. The crisis was a matter of burning interest to all European communists for whom the whole future of the revolutionary project started in 1917 depended on what happened in Germany. The thesis reconstructs the historical context of the Prison Notebooks year by year and identifies a series of notes - the 'German' notes - in which Gramsci theorises about questions suggested by current events in Germany. A few of these notes are in a concrete state and their German content is readily identified but many were written in general terms which must be decoded before their 'practical origins' in the German events become apparent. The method of decoding Gramsci's notes is to contextualise them. The order of chapters is chronological and each has three levels: (i) an account of Gramsci's personal drama - his moral struggle in the context of his deteriorating conditions of health - based largely on the Prison Letters. These letters are the outstanding human document of the European resistance to fascism, including resistance to German fascism at the hour of its victory; (ii) a reconstruction of Gramsci's knowledge of the German events based on a systematic reading of the political periodicals and newspapers he received on subscription in prison. These provided Gramsci with continuous news and comment on German affairs, the full extent of which has not been investigated (Appendix 2); (iii) a critical commentary on the 'German' notes following the chronological order established by Professor V. Gerratana in the critical edition of the Quaderni del Carcere (1975). The technical difficulties of determining the precise dates of the notes are sometimes considerable and have been a matter of scholarly dispute. Where the dates of the 'German' notes discussed in this thesis present particular problems, they are dealt with separately (Appendix 1). The conclusion draws together the conceptual threads running through the German notes and summarises the main features of Gramsci's interpretation. His theory of the rise of Hitler differs from those of other marxists inside and outside the Comintern for two reasons: firstly, his assimilation of concepts of non-marxist origin such as Weber's concept of the charismatic leader and Sorel's concept of the historical bloc; secondly, his rethinking from its Hegelian origins of marxism itself, which enables him to conceptualise aspects of the German crisis neglected by other marxists, notably the historic crisis of the traditional intellectuals, the counter revolutionary effects of civil society, and the role of the bureaucratic caste. In Gramsci's interpretation, Hitler comes to power in the context of a crisis of hegemony marked by the breakdown of the 'ruling ideas'. The traditional intellectuals, the Prussian nobles, are unable to provide leadership in politics or culture. Despite the catastrophic nature of the economic crisis after 1929, it does not develop into a revolutionary situation because of the resistance presented by the superstructures of civil society (private armies, newspaper concentrations, and other elements), a complex network of 'trenches' which make up the ideological front of the dominant class. The crisis is solved by the transformation of traditional into charismatic authority through the sudden appearance of a "man of destiny". The charisma of Hitler depends on reinventing tradition, a process most visible in the 'symbiotic' dependence of the parties and ideologies of the German Right. The element of race, a subordinate element in traditional nationalist ideology, now becomes the nucleus of a new utopia - the 'Third Reich', Gramsci regards the Third Reich not as a revolution (which it claimed to be) but as a dynamic restoration founded on the traditional solidarity of the dominant agrarian-industrial bloc. Despite this, his final word on the 'monstrous' phenomenon of Hitlerism, written in 1935 in response to the first laws of the racial State, unmistakably registered the shock of the new.

Item Type: Thesis (PhD)
Keywords: Weimar Germany
Academic Units: The University of York > History (York)
Identification Number/EthosID: uk.bl.ethos.247031
Depositing User: EThOS Import (York)
Date Deposited: 09 Nov 2016 16:06
Last Modified: 09 Nov 2016 16:06
URI: http://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/14159

You do not need to contact us to get a copy of this thesis. Please use the 'Download' link(s) above to get a copy.
You can contact us about this thesis. If you need to make a general enquiry, please see the Contact us page.

Actions (repository staff only: login required)