Glyn-Davies, Adaleta
ORCID: 0000-0002-1397-2322
(2026)
Visual Narratives in Complex Systems: Mapping for Systemic Design Concerning Migratory Identities.
PhD thesis, University of Leeds.
Abstract
This PhD presents “Visual Narratives”– a boundary practice using visualisations and storytelling to undertake systems mapping with people of migratory background in Systemic Design (ScD). Situated within the UK immigration system as a paradigmatic “wicked problem,” this PhD explored how people with migratory backgrounds – including refugees, asylum seekers and third–country nationals – might overcome barriers to participation in ScD.
As a practice concerned with designing for complexity, ScD attends to how systems evolve and how they are experienced by people. Systemic insights shaped by trauma, legal insecurity and mistrust of authorities – common in migratory experiences – are often ambiguous and sensitive, making them difficult to accommodate meaningfully through traditional systems research tools such as system dynamics and causal loop diagrams (CLDs) and thereby further distancing migratory identities from participation in ScD. On the other hand, systemic designers who operate within industry settings still rely on standardised approaches which are designed to quantify, deliver at speed and ultimately save resource. This refers to the governance of “audit logics” that prioritise time–sensitive, quantitative frameworks, inadvertently excluding insights and knowledge which are difficult to articulate or standardise. To address these matters, this PhD adopted a multi–stranded research design to examine the potential of Visual Narratives from three interrelated perspectives: migratory participants with no prior technical knowledge of systems thinking; senior industry practitioners working across diverse ScD contexts; and the researcher, positioned simultaneously as a systemic designer and a migratory identity. Together, these perspectives enabled a critical examination of how Visual Narratives might operate in practice, how they are perceived within professional ScD settings, and how ScD with migratory identities might be more effectively researched and enacted in the future. This inquiry was undertaken through participatory workshops with migratory identities, semi–structured interviews with industry practitioners and reflexive visual experimentation informed by “messy” methods.
The findings indicate that when grounded in a trust-based approach, Visual Narratives used with migratory identities can generate experiential systemic insights comparable to those produced through formal systems mapping. For migratory participants, this approach supported engagement by mitigating linguistic, personality-based and education-related barriers, as well as deeper challenges associated with prior experiences of “systemic betrayal.” For designers, Visual Narratives were viewed as an inclusive and feasible means of developing systemic understanding with migratory identities and other groups considered “vulnerable,” however, concerns persisted regarding the use of language framed as “fluffy” and the difficulty of translating such insights into quantifiable outputs within fast–paced, KPI-driven environments.
Metadata
| Supervisors: | Wilson, Paul and Thoma, Andrea and Thang, Thang |
|---|---|
| Keywords: | Systemic Design, Systems Mapping, Visual Narratives, Migratory Identities, Complexity. |
| Awarding institution: | University of Leeds |
| Academic Units: | The University of Leeds > Faculty of Arts, Humanities and Cultures (Leeds) > School of Design (Leeds) |
| Date Deposited: | 06 Oct 2026 09:19 |
| Last Modified: | 06 Oct 2026 09:19 |
| Open Archives Initiative ID (OAI ID): | oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:39267 |
Download
Final eThesis - complete (pdf)
Embargoed until: 1 October 2028
Please use the button below to request a copy.
Filename: Visual Narratives in Complex Systems_ Doctoral Thesis by Adela Glyn-Davies -Final submission.pdf
Export
Statistics
Please use the 'Request a copy' link(s) in the 'Downloads' section above to request this thesis. This will be sent directly to someone who may authorise access.
You can contact us about this thesis. If you need to make a general enquiry, please see the Contact us page.