Mirza, Mahrukh (2008) E-Learning through a magnifying glass : exploring experiences of students and teachers in higher education. PhD thesis, University of Sheffield.
Abstract
The literature reveals a gap between expectations and outcomes of e-learning and the
need to develop a technologically and pedagogically effective e-learning environment.
The literature suggested that making the shift from a Behaviorist to Constructivist
approach could narrow this gap. Therefore, the aim of the study was to investigate and
determine if the shift from teacher-led (behaviourist) approach to learner-centred
approach (constructivist) could help in reducing the gap between expectations and
outcomes of e-learning. The focus of the research was on the roles of information and
computer technology in improving the quality of teaching and learning, and on looking
to future possibilities and challenges to facilitate the development of pedagogically
effective e-learning environment. In order to achieve the aim, the primary objective
was to examine and evaluate learners' and teachers' experiences of e-learning and how
e-learning has impacted on their expectations and what needs to be improved if they
are to meet these new expectations.
The study identified motivators and barriers to e-learning for teachers and learners and
recommended measures that might be taken to remove or lessen the impact of such
identified barriers. The study found that the online environment clearly has the
capability to propagate the constructivist approach by encouraging learner controlled,
critically reflected and deeper learning but also found that many students still preferred
the behaviourist approach to learning (direct instructions) and that the preferences for
the level of learner-control may also vary from culture to culture (Western culture may
emphasise learners' control over their environment while eastern cultures may
emphasise teachers' control). Therefore, constructivism may not be suitable to all
subjects and all students. The study concluded that placing a greater value on teachers
as the knowledge expert and on objectivism of knowledge (Behaviourism) or placing a
greater value on learners as independent and constructive learners (Constructivism)
creates a bias in either direction and results in unsatisfied learners and teachers. It was
established that it is important to tip the balance equally between teachers and learners
rather than making it completely student-centred or completely teacher-led approach.
The researcher coins it as `teacher-learner balanced' approach.
Metadata
Awarding institution: | University of Sheffield |
---|---|
Academic Units: | The University of Sheffield > Faculty of Medicine, Dentistry and Health (Sheffield) > Dentistry (Sheffield) |
Identification Number/EthosID: | uk.bl.ethos.499976 |
Depositing User: | EThOS Import Sheffield |
Date Deposited: | 07 Apr 2016 13:47 |
Last Modified: | 07 Apr 2016 13:47 |
Open Archives Initiative ID (OAI ID): | oai:etheses.whiterose.ac.uk:10322 |
Downloads
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2a.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2a.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2a.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2b.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2b.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/2b.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02157.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02157.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02157.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1970.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1970.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1970.jpg
499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 1.doc
Filename: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 1.doc
Description: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 1.doc
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1967.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1967.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1967.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 3.doc
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 3.doc
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 3.doc
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 1
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 1
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 1
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02156.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02156.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02156.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1b.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1b.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1b.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01807.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01807.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01807.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/msc 2006/DSC03286.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/msc 2006/DSC03286.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/msc 2006/DSC03286.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01809.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01809.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01809.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 2.doc
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 2.doc
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Questionnaire Cycle 2.doc
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1966.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1966.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1966.jpg
499976_disc/Cultural Issues/CP Questionnaire
Filename: 499976_disc/Cultural Issues/CP Questionnaire
Description: 499976_disc/Cultural Issues/CP Questionnaire
499976.pdf
Filename: 499976.pdf
Description: 499976.pdf
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1a.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1a.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/1a.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3b.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3b.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3b.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/msc 2005/DSC02438.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/msc 2005/DSC02438.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/msc 2005/DSC02438.JPG
499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Questionnaire
Filename: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Questionnaire
Description: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Questionnaire
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01812.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01812.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01812.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1969.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1969.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1969.jpg
499976_disc/Cultural Issues/Cross Border Interview
Filename: 499976_disc/Cultural Issues/Cross Border Interview
Description: 499976_disc/Cultural Issues/Cross Border Interview
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1968.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1968.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 3rd cyle/diploma 2007/000_1968.jpg
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02158.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02158.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/therapists2005/DSC02158.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01813.JPG
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01813.JPG
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 1st Cycle/MSc 2004/DSC01813.JPG
499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3a.jpg
Filename: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3a.jpg
Description: 499976_disc/Learners Perspective/LP Nominal Group/NG 2nd Cycle/Diploma 2006/3a.jpg
499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 2.doc
Filename: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 2.doc
Description: 499976_disc/Teachers Perspective/TP Thematic Analysis 2.doc
Export
Statistics
You do not need to contact us to get a copy of this thesis. Please use the 'Download' link(s) above to get a copy.
You can contact us about this thesis. If you need to make a general enquiry, please see the Contact us page.